From the Library: covers, censuses, and editions, documented. Browse the Library →
SOJ Vagabond · Collecting
← Back to the Library

How do you identify a first printing of Japanese Vagabond?

The answer is printed in the back of the book: the colophon, not the cover.

Japanese publishing makes this easier than English collectors expect. Every Morning KC volume ends with an okudzuke, a colophon page that lists the book's printing history in plain type: the date of the first printing, and the date of the printing in your hand. A true first printing of Vagabond volume 1 reads as a first printing dated March 23, 1999. A fifth printing says fifth, with its own later date. The book confesses; you only have to turn to the last page and read it.

What the colophon does not reward is shortcut-hunting. ISBNs are shared across printings, obis are advertising, and condition is a separate question from printing. The five checks below are the order this shop works in.

VOLUME 1, FIRST PRINTING

The book to learn on

Vagabond Volume 1

March 23, 1999 · Morning KC
Vagabond volume 1 Japanese cover
Japan · Morning KCThe first printing of volume 1 left Kodansha on March 23, 1999, six months after the manga's debut: ISBN 978-4-06-328619-9. The colophon of a true first printing carries that date with the first-printing line.

Everything on this page can be checked against this one book. A first printing shows the first release date and the first-printing mark together in the colophon; later printings keep the ISBN and change the printing line and date.

THE CHECKS, IN ORDER

Five things to look at
1 · The colophon (okudzuke)
Japanese books print their biography at the back: publisher, imprint, and a line for each printing with its date. 第一刷, "first printing," beside the volume's release date is the whole game. Later printings say so, honestly, in the same place.
2 · The date must match the volume
Volume 1's first printing is dated March 23, 1999; volume 37's is July 23, 2014. A colophon date later than the release date means a later printing, however early the ISBN looks.
3 · The obi
The paper sash around the lower cover is advertising, discarded by most first buyers. A first printing with its obi intact is a completeness premium, not a different edition. Its absence proves nothing; its presence, with period tie-in text, supports everything.
4 · The ISBN
Necessary, never sufficient. Printings share an ISBN by design. The ISBN identifies the edition (volume 1 is 978-4-06-328619-9 in every printing); only the colophon identifies the printing.
5 · The insert and registration card
Early Morning KC volumes shipped with publisher inserts and reader cards. Their presence is a good sign of an untouched copy, and like the obi, a plus rather than a proof.
The English side
Viz singles state their printing in the indicia on the copyright page, "First printing" with the month and year on early volumes. The same discipline applies: read the small print, not the cover.
Which edition should a collector buy? →
All 37 Japanese covers →
MORE FROM THE VAGABOND ARCHIVE →
One shelf of the Library. Browse them all →

THE FIRST WORD

New pages and new pieces, first.