From the Library: covers, censuses, and editions, documented. Browse the Library →
SOJ Resident Evil ยท The Question
← Back to the Library

What happened to the Resident Evil Director's Cut soundtrack?

Because the 1998 replacement score was credited to a deaf genius who, sixteen years later, admitted he had not written it, and was not deaf.

This page prints the story at its documented weight: it is one credit inside an eighteen year ghostwriting record, and it happens to involve the most infamous basement in video game music.

THE REPLACEMENT

A new score for the Dual Shock edition

In August 1998 Capcom released Resident Evil: Director's Cut Dual Shock Ver., the original game with analog control, vibration, and a new symphonic soundtrack replacing the original score by Makoto Tomozawa, Koichi Hiroki, and Masami Ueda. The new music was credited to Mamoru Samuragochi, a composer celebrated in Japan as a digital age Beethoven: a man said to have composed masterworks after losing his hearing entirely.

The replacement was generally deemed inferior to the original it displaced, and one piece became notorious in its own right: the ambient theme for the mansion's basement, which has been ranked among the worst video game compositions of all time. The original score quietly returned in later editions; the 2006 Nintendo DS version restored the pre-Dual Shock soundtrack.

THE REVELATION

February 2014

On February 5, 2014, it was publicly revealed that the music attributed to Samuragochi since 1996 had mostly been ghostwritten by Takashi Niigaki, a composer and part time lecturer at the Toho Gakuen School of Music. Niigaki said Samuragochi was not deaf, had normal hearing, and had posed as deaf to build a mystique; that the cane was unnecessary; and that most of the biography in his album liner notes was fiction. Niigaki went to the press because a supposed Samuragochi composition was about to be skated to by Daisuke Takahashi at the Sochi Winter Olympics.

Samuragochi's handwritten statement of February 12 said he had partly regained his hearing three years earlier and that he was deeply ashamed of living a lie. At a Tokyo press conference on March 7 he admitted his hearing, while impaired, did not meet the legal requirements for deafness, and that he had returned his disability certificate. Hiroshima revoked the Citizens' Award it had given him in 2008. Doubts had been on paper earlier: a reporter for Aera magazine noticed in June 2013 that he answered questions before the interpreter finished and stood to answer a doorbell, and the magazine held the story.

THE VERDICT

What the credit on the box is worth
The game credit
Director's Cut Dual Shock Ver. (1998) and Onimusha: Warlords (2001) are the two game scores formerly credited to Samuragochi and since identified as Niigaki's work.
The wider record
The same identification covers his Symphony No. 1 "Hiroshima" and the works that built the Beethoven of Japan reputation across eighteen years.
The basement theme
Its reputation survives the scandal intact and is now doubled: the worst loved track in the series was written by a man whose name was not on it, for a composer who could hear it.
What Capcom ships now
Later reissues of the first game, including the DS edition, use the original 1996 score. The Dual Shock soundtrack remains the period artifact of the 1998 edition.
The History of Resident EvilThe Gallery
MORE FROM THE RESIDENT EVIL ARCHIVE →
One shelf of eighty-two in the Library. Browse them all →

THE FIRST WORD

New pages and new pieces, first.