From the Library: covers, censuses, and editions, documented. Browse the Library →
SOJ The Lord of the Rings · The Nemesis Patent
← Back to the Library

What is the Nemesis system, and why did Warner Bros. patent it?

It is a system that remembers you, and Warner Bros. patented it: US Patent No. 10,926,179, effective February 23, 2021.

The Nemesis system is the enemy system Monolith Productions built for Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor, released by Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment in September 2014. The game tracks individual Uruk, the orc officers of Sauron's army, once they do something notable, such as killing the player or surviving a fight with him. Tracked Uruk are promoted to captains inside a living hierarchy, with their own names, strengths and weaknesses.

The system runs on memory. An Uruk who survives an encounter remembers it when he meets Talion again. One thrown into a fire may return disfigured and looking for revenge. An Uruk who kills Talion gains power and rises in rank, which cancels the current mission and makes the next meeting harder. Killing captains weakens the army and drops runes for Talion's weapons, and later in the game Talion can brand captains, turn them, and trigger infighting inside the ranks. Deaths were also tracked online, so friends could take Vendetta missions against the Uruk who killed you.

Warner Bros. then patented the system itself. The patent, titled "Nemesis characters, nemesis forts, social vendettas and followers in computer games" and assigned to Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc., covers procedurally generated characters who sit in a hierarchy, remember and react to the player's actions, and change rank, appearance and behaviour because of them. The record shows what a patent does: it gives the holder the right to stop others using the claimed system, or to license it. The sources opened for this page document the grant and that legal effect. They do not include a Warner Bros. press statement explaining the motive, so this page does not invent one.

THE PATENT RECORD

Dates and numbers, as documented
Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor cover art
Shadow of Mordor · 2014
Monolith Productions, published by Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment. The game that introduced the Nemesis system, with Talion hunting Sauron's captains across Mordor.
Filed 2015, rejected, revised
The application was filed in March 2015, after the game's September 2014 release, with references dated as early as March 2015 and the push reported from March 2016. Patent reporting counts six rejections and revisions. The US Patent and Trademark Office issued a final rejection in November 2019, then a Notice of Allowance in October 2020.
Granted February 2021
US Patent No. 10,926,179. The USPTO released its issue notice on February 3, 2021, and the patent took effect on February 23, 2021. Warner Bros. has the option to maintain it until 2035 by paying the required fees. Wikipedia's article records the same patent under its US10926179B2 publication number, and records that the system was never used in any other game except the sequel, Shadow of War.

THE REACTION

Commentary, labelled as such
Tier 2 · Industry criticism
Eurogamer's February 2021 report collected the immediate reaction from other developers. Mike Bithell, creator of Thomas Was Alone, called the patent "really gross," arguing the Middle-earth games themselves built on mechanics replicated from other games, and added: "Be a better neighbour, WB." Obsidian design director Josh Sawyer reacted in blunter terms.
Tier 2 · The breadth worry
Narrative designer Cat Manning, quoted in the same report, worried the patent language was so broad that other emergent narrative systems could be described by it, and that smaller developers could not afford to test its enforceability in court. That is a stated concern from a working designer, presented here as commentary, not as a legal finding.
Tier 2 · The counterpoint
Vlambeer co-founder Rami Ismail, also quoted by Eurogamer, noted that a patent is not a copyright and does not by itself mean the holder will enforce it or win a case on it. Eurogamer also noted that game mechanic patents are not new: BioWare holds one for the Mass Effect dialogue wheel, and dialogue wheels still appeared in later games.
More from the Library →
MORE FROM THE LORD OF THE RINGS ARCHIVE →
One shelf of eighty-two in the Library. Browse them all →

THE FIRST WORD

New pages and new pieces, first.