Why Is Tekken 3 Considered the Best Fighting Game on the PlayStation?
Start with the record. Tekken 3's PlayStation version holds a 96 out of 100 Metacritic average, and Metacritic ranks it number 2 on its list of the greatest PlayStation games of any genre. Next Generation, reviewing the home version in 1998, put the claim in one sentence: "There is no better fighting game, on this system or any other."
The interesting question is what sits underneath the scores: a rebuilt fighting system with genuine 3D movement, a cast designed so that a complete beginner produces something beautiful by accident, and a home port that added more than the arcade original instead of settling for less.
THE TWO COVERS
The PlayStation versions

THE CASE
Four documented reasonsTHE HONEST CAVEAT
Consensus, not unanimityThe title is a consensus verdict, not a law. The Official UK PlayStation Magazine argued at the time that Street Fighter Alpha 3 would outlast Tekken 3, and 2D fighting loyalists had their own champion. EGM's own holdout reviewer, Sushi-X, docked Tekken 3 a point on principle, writing that no game that rewards newbies for button mashing would ever top his list.
What no rival on the system could match was the combination: the highest review averages of any PlayStation fighter, the deepest 3D fighting system on the console, an entry point low enough for a first time player, and a home package bigger than the arcade original. That is why the claim stuck, and why later lists kept ratifying it: Complex named it the fourth best fighting game of all time in 2011, and PlayStation: The Official Magazine was already calling it one of the finest fighting games ever made in 2009.